clock menu more-arrow no yes
In-N-Out Burger in the foreground is a mere 1.43 miles away from Shake Shack at New York-New York.
In-N-Out Burger in the foreground is a mere 1.43 miles away from Shake Shack at New York-New York.
Amelinda B Lee

Las Vegas: The Only Place You Can Get Shake Shack and In-N-Out Burgers Fresh

Everything you need to know about the burgers, the fries, the shakes, ambiance, trays, bathrooms and more at Shake Shack and In-N-Out Burger. The two restaurants sit less than two miles apart, and until Shake Shack opens in Austin, Texas, Las Vegas is the only place you can compare both while they're hot.

Since late December, Las Vegas has been the only place in the world where you can get both Shake Shack and In-N-Out Burger fresh for a true taste comparison. Shake Shack opened at the front of New York-New York and In-N-Out Burger on Dean Martin Drive sit a mere 1.43 miles away from eat other, making it easy to pick up one and take it to the other for a taste test.

They represent each coast. Shake Shack was born in New York City in Madison Square Park in 2000. In-N-Out Burger launched in 1948 in Baldwin Park, Calif., with a drive-thru. Fans and detractors have argued about which burger is better. Here, a look at how each stacks up against the other.

In-N-Out Burger
Shake Shack

The exteriors of In-N-Out Burger and Shake Shack


How long does it take to get from your car to the restaurant?
Shake Shack:
The restaurant sits at the front of New York-New York, so guests park at the parking garage at the rear of the casino. It took five minutes and 21 seconds to walk from parking level 2 to the front door of Shake Shack.

In-N-Out Burger: The restaurant on Dean Martin Drive has its own parking lot surround the place. It took one minute to walk to the front door.

How far apart are the two restaurants?
Driving from New York-New York to In-N-Out Burger took five minutes and 31 seconds with bad timing on the lights on Tropicana Avenue.

In-N-Out Order Counter
Shake Shack order counter

The order counters at In-N-Out Burger, left, and Shake Shack

How do you order?
Shake Shack: Pick from one of two lines at Shake Shack. One outside is strictly for beer, drinks, shakes, custards, concretes (and even swag). The other inside is for food.

In-N-Out: You can go through the drive-thru to order or walk up to the counter.

How long does it take to order?
Shake Shack: Fourteen seconds

In-N-Out Burger: One minute and 15 seconds

In-N-Out Burger Double-Double, fries and vanilla shake, top, and Shake Shack Double Shack Burger, fries and vanilla shake.


The order
Shake Shack:
Double Shack Burger, fries and a vanilla shake

In-N-Out Burger: Double-Double, fries and a vanilla shake

The cost
Shake Shack:
Double Shack Burger was $7.99, fries $2.95 and vanilla shake $5.25 for a total of $17.50.

In-N-Out Burger: Double-Double was $3.35, fries $1.60 and vanilla shake $2.10 for a total of $7.62.

Note: One Double Shack Burger costs more than an entire meal at In-N-Out Burger.

What if I don't want a shake?

Both outlets offer Coca-Cola products to drink.

What if I want alcohol?
Shake Shack: Wines and beers, including Shake Shack’s own brands.

In-N-Out Burger: Heck, no.

Buzzer at Shake Shack

How do I get my order?
Shake Shack: Buzzer goes off when your order is ready. Guests walk up to the counter to pick up their tray.

In-N-Out Burger: Employees call out numbers on the bottom of the ticket to alert guests when their orders are ready. Again, guests walk up to the counter to pick up their order.

In-N-Out Burger Condiments
Shake Shack condiments

In-N-Out Burger condiments, left, and Shake Shack condiments


What condiments are available?
Shake Shack:
Ketchup and mustard in a dispenser, as well as salt, pepper and mayonnaise.

In-N-Out Burger: Ketchup and mustard in a dispenser, as well as salt, pepper, hot peppers and pickles.

In-N-Out Burger seating
Shake Shack seating

In-N-Out Burger seating, left, and Shake Shack seating


Where do you sit?
Shake Shack:
The restaurant may be dubbed a roadside burger stand, but Shake Shack is pretty chic for fast-casual food. Reclaimed lumber and reused bowling alley lanes make up the tables. A roulette wheel that flashes is the overhead light. Booths and tables are all around.

In-N-Out Burger: This has the feel of a diner out of the ’50s with its stark white light, no music and tables and booths.

How long to get your order?
Shake Shack:
Six minutes and 23 seconds

In-N-Out Burger: Eight minutes and 14 seconds

In-N-Out Burger tray Amelinda B Lee
Shake Shack tray

In-N-Out Burger tray, left, and Shake Shack tray


What is your order delivered on?
Shake Shack:
Metal tray

In-N-Out Burger: Red tray

The In-N-Out Burger Double-Double and the Shake Shack Double Shack Burger


The burgers
Shake Shack:
This burger features two burgers, lettuce, tomato, cheese and Shake sauce. The burger is made with 100 percent all-natural beef and the bun is a Martin’s potato bun.

In-N-Out Burger: This burger features two burgers, lettuce, tomato and optional onions. In-N-Out Burger uses "100 percent American beef." The bun is "old-fashioned, slow-rising sponge dough."

In-N-Out Burger fries and Shake Shack fries
In-N-Out Burger fries
Shake Shack fries

In-N-Out Burger fries and Shake Shack fries


The fries
Shake Shack:
Crinkle cut Yukon potatoes

In-N-Out Burger: Hand-cut potatoes cooked in 100 percent vegetable oil.

In-N-Out Burger and Shake Shack vanila shakes
In-N-Out Burger vanilla shake
Shake Shack vanilla shake

In-N-Out Burger and Shake Shack vanilla shakes


Shakes
Shake Shack:
Made with custard made in house daily with "real sugar, no corn syrup, and milk from dairy farmers who pledge not to use artificial growth hormones."

In-N-Out Burger: Made with real ice cream.

In-N-Out Burger bathrooms
Shake Shack bathroom

In-N-Out Burger restroom, left, and Shake Shack restroom


The restroom
Shake Shack:
Decorated with a New York skyline. Hand dryers for drying off hands.

In-N-Out Burger: Stark like most fast food restaurant bathrooms. Paper towels for drying off hands.

Swag
Shake Shack:
Find everything from T-shirts and hats to onesies for the little ones.

In-N-Out Burger: This location has the Company Store next door where you can buy T-shirts, hats, iPhone covers and more.

In-N-Out Burger

7467 East Frank Lloyd Wright Boulevard, , AZ 85260 (800) 786-1000 Visit Website
Eater Guides

Las Vegas Dining 101: A Guide for Eating and Drinking in Sin City

Eater Inside

A Dramatic Driftwood Tree Anchors the Mexican Dining Room at Ray Garcia’s ¡Viva!

AM Intel

Kyle Canyon Treasure Mt. Charleston Lodge ‘Fully Engulfed’ in Flames During an Early Morning Fire

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Eater Las Vegas newsletter

The freshest news from the local food world